It's not at all true that all unhappy families are different, no matter what famous writers may say -- there are only so many kinds of unhappiness, and they recur again and again. And unhappy families breed unhappy people, who again fall into types -- the sullen teenage boy, the cold and controlling mother, the quietly alcoholic father, the introverted anorexic daughter. They might not be part of the same family in any particular story, but we know these people when we see them -- know them from fiction and from life.
So it's no knock against Ludovic Deburme's engrossing graphic novel Lucille to say that we know its characters already: the young lovers Lucille and Vladimir, and their very different but equally damaging parents. Debeurme tells their separate stories through mostly quiet scenes, made immediate by his large, open drawings and Lucille's lack of panel borders: each drawing flows into the next, as Lucille and Vladimir's stories flow together eventually, as they meet and run away together, to get away from the landscape and people who made them what they are. (And, of course, in the hopes that doing so will let them escape the people they are.)
This is the story of two sad, damaged young people, who cling to each other in a world that's not so much hostile as just unconcerned. They do find love with each other, as much as either of them can, and they even find a place where they might be happy. But can damaged people really be happy, even if they look to have their whole lives still to go? That's the thorny question of Lucille: whether there is such a thing as a happy family, or any true lasting happiness anywhere in this world. Lucille and Vladimir's journey is touching and inspiring and sad all at the same time; we desperately want them to transcend themselves at the same time that we're sure that they can't possibly do so.
I'm encouraged to learn that Lucille is not the end of the story; Debeurme has already created a sequel, Renee, which was published last year in his native France. So what seems to be an ending here might not be as final as it looks; there is always hope.
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(395)
-
▼
April
(54)
- Read in April
- Reviewing the Mail: Week of 4/28
- Melankolins högborg
- My Current Zen Koan
- In Which A Lying Liar Lies
- Mormon Eschatology
- Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About the Hugo ...
- Even More Awards I Neglected to Mention
- Tor Dumps DRM
- Barry Eisler Continues to Shill for Amazon
- G.B.H. Says Check It Out
- World Book Night!
- Secret Codes
- Reviewing the Mail: Week of 4/21
- Unicorn Being a Jerk by C.W. Moss
- Sandy Denny - 34 år senare
- My Favorite Song on That Record Is....
- Lucille by Ludovic Debeurme
- Stress-signaler
- Asking the Wrong Questions
- All Them Furriners
- Believe!
- Creepy WSJ Article About the Ever-Shrinking Workspace
- People Who Complain About Their Taxes Aren't Allow...
- Totally Urban Fantasy
- Because This Point Cannot Be Made Often Enough
- Joe the Barbarian by Grant Morrison & Sean Murphy
- Even the Former Head of the TSA...
- Relevant to My Interests
- Reviewing the Mail: Week of 4/14
- The Fry Chronicles by Stephen Fry
- Night Shade's Massive 50% Off Sale
- Vårpromenad med insikt
- Lika mycket som alla andra?
- The Perils of a Star Wars-Themed Nursery
- Kindle Fire Costs More to Produce Than Retail Price
- What Fictional Character Shares Your Birthday?
- A Book You Probably Haven't Read, But Should
- 3 of Agency 5 Settle With DOJ
- All Hail the New Boss! Same as the Old Boss!
- What It's Like to Be an Eisner Judge
- The IKEA Suburb of London?
- The World Is Rich and Strange
- Reviewing the Mail: Week of 4/7
- Other Award News: Stoker Winners, Eisner Nominees,...
- 2012 Hugo Nominees
- Kultur - mer än underhållning
- The Unhelpful Phrase In My Head All Day
- Allan Thomas - Ett stänk av 70-talet
- The Psychopath Test by Jon Ronson
- (Belated) Clarke Award Nominees
- Did We Live and Fight in Vain?
- News of the (Prior) Day
- Reviewing the Mail: Week of 3/31
-
▼
April
(54)
Popular Posts
-
Sandy Denny dog 1978. Thea Gilmore föddes 1979. Ändå upptäckte hon Sandy Dennys musik via hennes pappas skivsamling. Nu, många år senare, er...
-
Just nu hinner jag knappt med livets vardagliga nödvändigheter, men snart kommer oktober och då lättar det. Och det kommer en massa spännand...
-
Haruki Murakami Bingo , from the inimitable Incidental Comics . This is only one square -- clickthrough for the entire thing.
-
NoiseTrade offers a lot of free music -- usually samplers or live EPs -- but occasionally there's a full album up there. Now is one of t...
-
Mark Davis - Eliminate The Toxins Vet inte hur det kommmer sig, men det kommer så mycket bra musik från Kanada att det verkar vara mer regel...
-
Det kan man ju inte tro... Lucinda Williams fyller 60 i dag! Jag tror att det var Emmylou Harris som en gång sa något i stil med: "Jag ...
-
And via James Nicoll : I Am A: True Neutral Human Bard (5th Level) Ability Scores: Strength- 12 Dexterity- 12 Constitution- 14 Intelligence...
-
This is my first "Reviewing the Mail" post to be composed in Blogger's hideous new template -- it's as Google-riffic as an...
-
Top Shelf, one of the finest publishers of interesting comics on this or any other continent, is having one of their periodic amazing sales ...
-
But I am stealing it anyway, because it is awesome: (It also reminds me of some psuedo-Impressionist watercolors -- also with tasteful A.A. ...